I keep running into a conflict between what I think is happening on the show (that the show is playing a long game and subtly criticizing Shue) and what I'm afraid is happening (that they think Shue's a good guy instead of a Nice Guy (tm)).

And Finn's inability to commit to anything is actually getting on my nerves. I can forgive a lot for being rock stupid, but Brittany's dumber than he is and she is actually committed to more than he is.